Locations
Huntington, Northport and Greenport, about 55 miles end to end. Same chicken in each, a different view out of the window. All three are closed on Mondays.
Lunch through dinner
9 Gristmill Row · (631) 555-0161
Next table for two:
Lunch through dinner
31 Scudder Wharf · (631) 555-0164
Next table for two:
Lunch through dinner
22 Sterling Slip · (631) 555-0168
Next table for two:
Huntington · since 1994 · 64 seats
Sixty-four seats, a counter facing the fire, and the rotisserie Paul built in 1994 still doing the work. Come hungry and do not expect quiet.
Lunch through dinner
Northport · since 2006 · 52 seats
The deck opens in May and stays open as long as anyone will sit on it. Sunday supper for the whole table started here in 2006.
Lunch through dinner
Greenport · since 2018 · 46 seats
Heavy beams, ship lamps and the ferry outside the window. Close enough to the North Fork farms that the salad is picked the same morning.
Lunch through dinner
Which room
What each room is best at, from people who have eaten in all three more often than is sensible.
Lunch at the counter, big family tables, a bird to go on the way home.
The original room. The first rotisserie is still on the wall, and still working.
The deck in summer, Sunday supper, an early table before the theater.
A block from the harbor, with a deck in summer. Home of the Sunday supper.
Lunch off the ferry, a table after the vineyards, the bread class.
The old chandlery by the ferry. Closed Mondays and Tuesdays out of season.